*The Picador Paperback edition of Michael Herr’s 1977 book Dispatches.
This cover reminds me of M*A*S*H. In both, a weird brand of 70s minimalism flavors the apocalypse with humor and whimsy. The saturated green helmet with its slogan ‘HELL SUCKS’ and a teardrop peace sign in vivid yellow, nestles in a hyperbolic (but mostly true) blurb from John Le Carré. It’s certainly the best book I’ve ever read on men and war in any time, but then again I haven’t read many true war narratives.
When I hold this book in my hand, I can see the yellow of the passing years on the white cover, the thumbprints of everyone who has picked it up over the years shining in the light. It feels like a cheaply-made, but beautiful communiqué, delivered personally by a friend.
When you get down to it though, Dispatches, isn’t much of a narrative. It’s more a patchwork of impressions. Herr uses an erratic, stream-of-consciousness style. He’s a straight, war-hardened Hunter S. Thompson with big balls and a bigger heart. His reports stick close to the dirt as he follows the lowest ranks of the most active units in the marines. He’d rather tell us what the stoned grunts are talking about than the generals or the intelligence agencies. Herr’s Vietnam War is in no way romanticized. He refrains from the easy exoticism of Hollywood’s Vietnam films like Platoon and Apocalypse Now. There are no easy political answers like you might find in Peter Davis’s powerful documentary Hearts and Minds.
Herr’s gift is the ability to show the horror and madness of war without any bloviating rhetoric, just the facts and the action of it all. He shows most of the men in a human light, which is what they deserve, no matter the atrocities some of them participated in. Herr’s strongest moment is his long description of the press in Vietnam. The journalist’s odd hypocritical stance and parasitic nature is set into stunning relief against a war most of them objected to.
Dexter Filkins accomplished something similar for the Iraq War in his brilliant 2008 book The Forever War, but some of the resistant glamour of the journalist has been lost in the intervening 40 years. The alienation is stronger in Iraq, it seems, and perhaps the disinterest of civilians back home has helped make the Armed Forces more callous. Let the draft be reinstituted and see how oblivious we remain.
Related Links: